Benton's Blueberry Old Fashioned: A Bacon Fat-Washed Bourbon Cocktail with Blueberries, Orange, and Maple
A cocktail for breakfast with Paul Bunyan
A cocktail for breakfast with Paul Bunyan
Appalachians are many and varied, but they all wear plaid. In November, the region viewed from a satellite would look like it's been overlaid with a giant sheet of tartan. And, by now, that plaid most certainly comes in flannel. This is a heady time of year. The air is crisp, the leaves have fallen, and soon snow will coat the leafless branches of our great deciduous trees, making you feel like you're walking under a chandelier if you’re among the hardwoods.
This is the environment that gave us the legendary/mythical/true figure Paul Bunyan. Paul Bunyan comes to us from the oral traditions of logging camps in the North Woods. He is a fixture in both American and Canadian folklore, known for superhuman feats of labor and strength. While most of what we know about Paul Bunyan comes to us from myth and legend, there are a couple of candidates for the individual he’s based on. The first is Fabian “Saginaw Joe” Fournier, who was a French Canadian logging boss. He was a big dude who liked to brawl in his spare time. This predictably ends in Saginaw Joe’s death while brawling with a stonemason—both professions build a ready stock of muscle, frustration, and skills with tools that easily become weapons. Accordingly, the stonemason, Adolphus “Blinky” Robinson, killed Saginaw Joe with a mallet blow to the head.
The other candidate is Bon Jean, a character associated with the 1837 Papineau Rebellion in French Canada. This rebellion arose over a list of grievances from French Canadians against their British overlords that would be easily recognizable to any American. This spurred a bunch of hangings and the shipping of many rebels to Australia. It is easy to see how “Bon Jean” might be shortened to Bunyan by Michiganders and others in and around the North Woods and Great Lakes, stretching from Superior out through the St. Lawrence to Montreal.
This week's cocktail is well represented by such characters. Though it gives the air of being from an older time, the bacon-fat-washed Benton’s Old Fashioned dates to 2007. It was created by Don Lee, a famous bartender at Please Don’t Tell in NYC. That year was awash with bars and restaurants trying modern culinary techniques, and apparently Don Lee was inspired by the famous Momofuku, which, at the time of the drink’s creation, was itself experimenting with dishes centered around cured meats — this will not be a post for our vegetarian and vegan friends, but we’ll rectify that in the coming weeks. The Benton’s Old Fashioned gets its name from Allan Benton of Tennessee’s Benton’s Country Hams. The drink launched a fat-washing revolution in mixology. Dave Arnold’s Liquid Intelligence further fueled the fire by offering solid, accessible advice on how to fat-wash spirits with all manner of culinary fat sources. If it’s not obvious, all of these places are worth your patronage.
In this week’s version of the drink, we’re adding a blueberry note to morph the drink into a more complete breakfast libation, rich, silky, luxurious. It’s the perfect drink for a lazy holiday morning that will turn into a long day catching up with family and friends. As far as cocktails go, it's great comfort food, and one could easily batch this for a large group by scaling up the recipe below. If you try it, let us know in the notes, and especially if you’d like to share a recipe for some good blueberry pancakes.
Let’s tip one.
To bacon-fat-wash your bourbon, follow the process for infusing and removing the fat as for Run for the Roses. BEWARE: bacon is intense and very potent. You do not need nearly as much of it to wash a spirit as you would other fats.
Bacon Fat Washed Bourbon
Blueberry Cinnamon Rum
This stuff is good to have around and is great on its own on the rocks. Use a gold or aged rum; it doesn’t need to be expensive.
In a large container (a mason jar is great), muddle the blueberries and cinnamon together, making sure to burst the berries and reduce the cinnamon to shards. Stir in the rum and let it infuse for about a week, agitating gently along the way. Then strain the liquid off the debris. Add the simple syrup and bottle. On to the cocktail!
Thoroughly chill your glass. This is a stirred drink. Add your ingredients, sans garnish, to a mixing glass, then fill it with a mixture of large bergs and smaller shards of ice. Stir until the drink is thoroughly chilled, then fine-strain into your glass, which you’ve filled with a single large berg of ice — the bigger, the better. Express the orange oils over the drink and discard the peel. Garnish with your fresh blueberries, three or five, and enjoy!
Glass: Rocks glass
You can, of course, make a Maple Old Fashioned without bacon-fat-washing the bourbon; it just wouldn’t be a Benton’s Old Fashioned. If you don’t like the notion of washing the bourbon yourself, Fee Bros now makes Bacon Fat Wash bitters you can add to your drink, presumably in proportions similar to aromatic bitters. As for bourbons, I prefer a wheated bourbon rather than high-rye in this cocktail; choose what you like. Given our focus on the Great North, there is a certain Canadian rye whiskey, wrapped in the colors of blueberry, that would go well here. Let me know below if you’d like a vegetarian or vegan version of this drink.
This is a variation on the Benton’s Old Fashioned because I wanted to plant that idea of bacon and a stack of blueberry pancakes in the back of your mind. But you certainly don’t need the blueberry spirits in there. You’ll get a more flavorful Maple note if you use Grade B Maple Syrup, or what the Maple Supreme Overlords now call “Grade A Dark.” It’s collected later in the season and has a darker, stronger flavor. It’ll stand up to what is a spirit-forward drink with an acute savory note from the bacon.
To that point, you can change the character of this drink a bit by choosing different bacon based on smoke. I used hickory above, but apple would work well too. If you don’t like smoke, simply choose a cured bacon. This sort of washing is endemic these days. I’ve seen drinks washed with chicken and beef fat, too. I can’t vouch for those, but this one is tasty and will be just what you need in the morning to prep for a long day of cooking with folks you love, and hopefully, like.
Thanksgiving is only the opening foray into the holiday season that stretches to mid-February. Next week, join us at the Appalachian Speakeasy for a holiday Martini to still your nerves for friends and family. We’ll make a single and a freezer-door version for emergencies. See you then, and drop a note below if you try the Benton’s Old Fashioned or let us know how you make yours.
This blog is, as ever, an opinionated take on drinks.